
By Deroy Murdock
Matthew Charles Albertell might as well be Matthew Charles Albert Hell.
Albertell, my long-time friend and associate, is trapped in a cinematically rich criminal/civil legal Hades that could have been screen-written by Franz Kafka and directed by George Orwell. Since summer 2025, this Inferno has featured threats of criminal charges without crimes, apparent NYPD misconduct, and even police abuse of Albertell’s parents.
I have known Albertell since 2018. We have collaborated on numerous political and commercial endeavors. I admire his patriotism and professional skills. Thus, I have been stunned as New York Police Department officers have hounded him over alleged extortion and grand larceny. Never mind that Albertell saw his landlords steal his personal property.
Albertell moved into Manhattan’s 75 West End Avenue in early August 2025. He rented a room in Apartment P18D after cordial discussions with Shahzad Pirvani, a Pakistani immigrant. Under their oral agreement, Shahzad would be Albertell’s sole roommate.
But within weeks, their relationship curdled as Albertell opposed the arrival of an additional roommate, beyond Shahzad, which violated the apartment’s lease.
Things deteriorated badly last December when Shahzad and his brother Jahanzeb snuck into Albertell’s bedroom and swiped his security cameras. I have seen the chilling videos of the Pirvani brothers walking through Albertell’s room, right until each camera was disconnected, and its feed went black. This turbocharged the dispute between Albertell and the Pirvanis. They tried to force him out. He invoked his legal right to remain in the bedroom that he agreed to rent.
The situation grew so grim by December 11 that two unidentified NYPD officers showed up at his door. An audio recording of Albertell’s encounter clearly establishes that the Pirvanis needed a court order to enter his bedroom or drive him off the premises.
One cop told Albertell that, under New York law, he enjoyed certain rights, given that his rental exceeded 30 days:
“Technically, the landlords, or owner of the property cannot remove you,” the 20th Precinct officer said. “They have to take you to Landlord/Tenant Court, and then from there, the judge will order a court order, where the Sheriff’s Department — we really don’t get involved — and the Sheriff’s Department will come and, you know, serve you the court order saying that you have to vacate the premises by a certain time.”
This wise cop perfectly described what should have happened next. Instead, the exact opposite ensued.
Despite the wise cop’s proper understanding of the law, about a half-dozen other NYPD officers, including Michael I. McGoldrick (Badge No. 13374), entered Albertell’s residence, without his consent. This major operation included these policemen from the 20th Precinct, staffers from a professional moving company, and the Pirvanis all joining forces to conduct this illegal activity. These dodgy cops converged on Albertell’s apartment and bedroom, ignored his vocal and legitimate objections, and oversaw the Pirvanis’ removal of his clothing, jewelry, accessories, and other personal effects.
“December 15 was the day the Pirvani brothers came with movers, and the apartment was stripped,” Albertell told me. “My room was left with only the mattress on the floor.”
A legal pleading dated October 20, 2026, confirms Albertell’s account, and from no less an authority than Jahanzeb Pirvani. As he affirmed, under penalty of perjury: “On December 15 [2025], after several hours and only with the NYPD officers present, we entered and removed certain of our personal belongings under their supervision.” These “personal belongings” apparently included Albertell’s stuff.
Entering Albertell’s bedroom and swiping his property without a court order, as NYPD officers provided “their supervision,” violated nearly identical state and local laws. As Google’s Gemini service summarized the relevant statutes: “New York City Administrative Code § 26-521 and New York Real Property Actions and Proceedings Law § 768, it is illegal to evict or attempt to evict any lawful occupant who has resided in a dwelling for 30 consecutive days or longer (or who holds a lease) without a formal court-ordered eviction warrant or government vacate order.” Illegal actions include “threatening the use of force to induce the occupant to vacate the dwelling unit,” and “removing the occupant’s possessions from the dwelling unit.” (Emphasis added.)
RPAPL § 749 directs courts to issue relevant warrants primarily “to the sheriff of the county.” The NYPD is not the New York County Sheriff. Albertell recalled: “No one showed me a warrant or court order.”
The 20th Precinct’s officers on December 15 also appeared to violate New York Attorney General Letitia James’ October 17, 2022, memorandum to law-enforcement agencies across the Empire State. “Unlawful evictions are now criminal matters and law enforcement should play an active role in enforcing the law,” AG James wrote. “Swift action on the part of law enforcement will help ensure that people are not removed from their homes without due process.” These include any occupant with “a written or oral lease” and “at least 30 days” of tenancy. Albertell satisfied both conditions.

AG James added: “Law enforcement officers should not be involved with the execution of a warrant of eviction by a Marshal, Sheriff or City Constable. Instead, the law enforcement officer should only be available to assist to keep the peace.” Multiple NYPD officers standing in Albertell’s bedroom and providing what Pirvani called “supervision” (as the photo above demonstrates) is no way to “keep the peace.”
While these NYPD officers spurned the law and their state attorney general, Housing Court Judge Frances A. Ortiz did not. In fact, on December 29, she ordered Brodcom West Development Company, 75 West End Avenue’s owner, to return Albertell’s key and restore his access to Apartment P18D.
Brodcom indicated in court records that it had no dispute with Albertell or his rent payments.
Even though the Pirvanis stole his property while NYPD officers from the 20th Precinct provided “supervision,” Albertell, somehow, faces potential grand larceny and extortion charges, never mind that he stole nothing and blackmailed no one. He says that his attorney heard an NYPD officer cite those crimes in a phone call. Albertell also recalls Manhattan Assistant District Attorney Alec Simon discussing prosecution for grand larceny and extortion during their 90-minute Zoom discussion on September 22.
Last August 11, Albertell hired Pierre Sussman, Esq. to represent him in the criminal case that climbed like a toxic weed from the fertile soil of the Pirvanis’ civil action against Albertell. On that day, Albertell texted NYPD Detective Christopher Latty (Badge No. 1604). “My attorney will reach out to you. Please be on the lookout for his call shortly.” Albertell says that on August 17, Sussman told Latty that the NYPD henceforth should communicate directly with him as Albertell’s counsel and leave his client alone.
Message not received.
That afternoon, Latty’s colleague Sergeant Stephen M. Daly (Badge No. 944) of NYPD’s Warrant Bureau texted Albertell at 2:47 p.m. to “schedule a day with you to come in and get this handled. The other option is track you down arrest you and bring you there myself,” referring to Central Booking, AKA The Tombs. “This isn’t going away until you handle it.”
On September 8, at 8:34 a.m., Sussman texted the NYPD and instructed, “please do not contact my client. He is represented by counsel,” specifically Sussman.
Message still not received.
At 4:55 that afternoon, Daly texted Albertell about a surrender date: “Not showing tomorrow isn’t a clear sign you have no intention of ever coming in, claiming you are out of state doesn’t work.” (This was no “claim,” as Albertell frequently spends extended periods outside New York, including that very day.)
Missed calls on Matthew Albertell’s phone.
If Albertell craved attention, he sure got it on September 9. Daly (apparently using Latty’s phone) called Albertell’s cell seven times, from 8:07 a.m. to 1:37 p.m. The average stalker gives his prey more space.
Daly must have been tossing and turning in bed over Albertell. Rather than get some shuteye, Daly texted him on September 30 at 2:56 a.m.: “Next step I will be placing a travel alert on you and will have no problem picking you up from whatever airport you attempt to fly from since you claim to constantly be out of state.”
That same day, Daly texted Albertell’s father. Daly also texted Albertell’s mother at 9:22 a.m. At 11:52 a.m., Daly texted again, about her son: “He has an open report against him in Manhattan and it isn’t going away until he comes into the precinct.” Albertell’s mother hyperventilated, fled the middle-school classroom where she teaches special-needs students, and tried to compose herself
Daly’s repeated calls and texts to Albertell, and his parents, despite Sussman’s direct instructions to the contrary, might constitute aggravated harassment under New York State Penal Law § 240.30(2), especially if Daly harbored “intent to harass or threaten another person” and made a telephone call “whether or not a conversation ensues, with no purpose of legitimate communication.”
This would not be Daly’s first legal challenge. He made quite a splash on 50-a.org, “a searchable website of NYC Civilian Complaint Review Board records and related public NYPD data.” According to that source, Daly’s record includes two “substantiated” complaints from May 2020 by a 60-64-year-old Hispanic male. These involved “Abuse of Authority: Property damaged” and “Abuse of Authority: Entry of Premises.”
Daly also triggered legal settlements of $25,000, $27,000, and a whopping $1.598 million. That payout went to plaintiff Gonzalo Cortes. On July 1, 2013, this website reports, Cortes “was beaten when he asked to use the restroom, causing him a tear in his shoulder. Plaintiff alleges he was met with indifference with respect to his medical condition, and also that officers failed to intervene on his behalf.”
Albertell and Sussman repeatedly have sought an arrest warrant and its underlying evidence of probable cause. The NYPD has shown neither to either. Police at the 20th Precinct seem hellbent on arresting Albertell, despite this elusive warrant. Then again, this “warrant” could be a bluff, to lure Albertell into the 20th Precinct, so that his tormentors can arrest him via an “I-Card.” Unlike a proper arrest warrant, I-cards involve no proof of probable cause, no judicial oversight, and no ensuing court order. The NYPD can create them just ’cause.
Manhattan ADA Simon has yet to file actual charges against Albertell, although he has pursued a case of petit larceny against Jahanzeb Pirvani (but, oddly, not his brother) for allegedly snatching Albertell’s security cameras.
Sergeant Jason Chung (Badge No. 1955) received Albertell’s evidence about these outrages. The 20th Precinct has ignored these complaints.
The NYPD Internal Affairs Bureau knows these sordid details. Based on my inquiries, it opened two log numbers on Albertell’s case: 2026-32319 and 2026-41421.
Understandably, Albertell has had it with what he correctly calls a massive injustice and “the worst year and a half of my life.” He has begun a public-relations campaign to clear his name, amid tireless efforts to smear him via social-media posts, seemingly at the Pirvanis’ hands.
Albertell used Google’s Gemini super-intelligence service to create two videos — here and here — that summarize his suffering. He also has launched a website that explains his side of this sordid tale and yet another website that he calls The Record. Albertell invites Americans to use it to submit and archive their experiences with police misconduct.
Albertell has begun speaking with journalists about this baseless case. Ending this fiasco now will keep it from festering into a throbbing black eye for the NYPD.
Those of us who value the NYPD and its valiant officers would prefer that they receive credit for their courage and sacrifice than bad ink for the shenanigans of shady cops. Of course, the first aid for shady cops is sunshine.
(The Pirvani brothers, contacted through their lawyers, and the Manhattan District Attorney’s Office did not respond to repeated inquiries. Aside from the Internal Affairs Bureau, which furnished its log numbers for this case, the NYPD also did not reply to requests for comment.)
Deroy Murdock is a Manhattan-based Fox News Contributor and contributing editor with The American Spectator.
The post This Opinion Just In… Shady Cops to Crime Victim: Go to Hell! appeared first on The Gateway Pundit.


